I'm on the same boat with regard to Ravelry (down to the Herdwick mode). I already have so much saved there, anyway. I wanted to see if Ribblr could be useful since a number of people did move there, but the #craftingrevolution is rather silly.

Hm, I also prefer to use paper patterns. The fact that their pattern format lets you "select your size with smart sizing, translate patterns, use built-in videos & charts" is interesting, but most of those are easy to do on one's own.

I've used KnitCompanion a couple times and it can time how long you spend on a project, but your method is very charming. I love that you get to record which songs you listened to as well.

Thanks for sharing your thoughts!