lizcommotion: A hand-drawn/colored lovely little creature with a knitted cap and piles of yarn behind it knitting a scarf (knitting creature)
[personal profile] lizcommotion posting in [community profile] knitting
Question about sweater pattern alteration here:

I tend to pick patterns to pieces and combine the bits I like. I'm planning to knit caramel, which is a top-down cardigan that's got a lot of positive ease and is very drape-y, using some Malabrigo rastita and DK/light worsted handspun that's a mix of silk and wool.

My main question is, aside from me having to do math, is there a structural problem with me knitting in a looser gauge than the pattern calls for?

The pattern calls for 22 sts / 4 inches, and I just feel that because the yarn I have is very woolen and floofy, at that gauge it will be Too Stiff. Also, because chronic pain + hot flashes all the time, light weight cardigans are really more my style anyway.

I know for socks and things a looser gauge means you're more likely to get holes, and obviously it will be cooler (which I want). But other than that, is there any reason not to do it? I also know that because I'm using a lot of single ply, there will be Pilling Issues, but I can deal.

I knit a swatch with a gauge of 18 sts / 4 inches and I really like the way the fabric looks and drapes and feels so if there is not a problem other than those listed above, I will probably just go with that.


(no subject)

Date: 2016-01-15 12:09 pm (UTC)
grimmhill: (Science)
From: [personal profile] grimmhill
The only problem I would foresee is that the drape of the front pieces may change. A loose gauge means a fabric with less body, so it may puddle more. I'm not sure how to assess the difference using a more robust mixed yarn at a looser gauge will make though.

(no subject)

Date: 2016-01-15 08:49 pm (UTC)
turlough: line drawing of a tiny knitting cat with big ball of purple yarn, with the text "itty bitty knitting kitty" above ((other) knitter)
From: [personal profile] turlough
The thing I would worry about is that the fabric might sag under its own weight if it's knitted at too loose a gauge.Though with DK weight yarn that might not be too much of a problem.

(no subject)

Date: 2016-01-16 12:46 am (UTC)
hellkitty: (cat kitten peeping)
From: [personal profile] hellkitty
You might try, if you hate math, to do the adjustment numbers for the armholes and such, to select a smaller size than you would make for your measurements.

Socks are knitted tighter than 'recommended' gauge for yarn, because socks get a lot of terrible wear. Sweaters get worn, but nothing like getting rubbed a couple hundred times a wear against the heel of a shoe while sweating, so that's not really going to be an issue. :D

(no subject)

Date: 2016-01-16 03:14 am (UTC)
yanagi_wa: (Default)
From: [personal profile] yanagi_wa
It'll turn out a different size. Not sure how different or what direction it'll go. (too late at night for math.)



October 2017

8910111213 14

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags